Performance marketing and automation Built for operators
Response window 24h info@digitalkinginc.com
Digital King Marketing · Tech · Sales enablement

Bottle one is the hook. Supplements DTC Marketing Agency built on the refill.

Supplements DTC is a subscription business dressed up as consumer goods. Bottle one barely covers paid. The business lives on month two through month twelve, which means cadence, dunning, winback, and education are not afterthoughts. We run supplements brands against cohort LTV with FDA and Meta compliance baked into every asset.

Subscription
Offer ladder, cadence, margin protection, and a dunning sequence that actually recovers failed cards.
Education
Klaviyo plus SMS flows timed to ingredient dosing cycles. Nurture that teaches so the refill feels earned.
Compliance
FDA claim thresholds and Meta ad policy pre-review on every asset. The account stops getting flagged and the creative keeps shipping.
Where we run supplements programs
  • Meta Ads Compliance-aware creative
  • TikTok Ads Creator + Spark Ads
  • Klaviyo Education lifecycle flows
  • Subscription + Recharge Cadence + dunning engine
  • Recharge / Skio Offer ladder + winback
  • Google PMax Branded + category intent
  • Server-side Events Post-iOS attribution
  • Amazon Compliance Claims + listing review
  • Meta Ads Compliance-aware creative
  • TikTok Ads Creator + Spark Ads
  • Klaviyo Education lifecycle flows
  • Subscription + Recharge Cadence + dunning engine
  • Recharge / Skio Offer ladder + winback
  • Google PMax Branded + category intent
  • Server-side Events Post-iOS attribution
  • Amazon Compliance Claims + listing review
  • Meta Ads Compliance-aware creative
  • TikTok Ads Creator + Spark Ads
  • Klaviyo Education lifecycle flows
  • Subscription + Recharge Cadence + dunning engine
  • Recharge / Skio Offer ladder + winback
  • Google PMax Branded + category intent
  • Server-side Events Post-iOS attribution
  • Amazon Compliance Claims + listing review
  • Meta Ads Compliance-aware creative
  • TikTok Ads Creator + Spark Ads
  • Klaviyo Education lifecycle flows
  • Subscription + Recharge Cadence + dunning engine
  • Recharge / Skio Offer ladder + winback
  • Google PMax Branded + category intent
  • Server-side Events Post-iOS attribution
  • Amazon Compliance Claims + listing review
Why supplements founders hire us

What changes when a supplements brand stops optimizing to first-purchase ROAS.

The refill is the business.

Day 1 is acquisition. Day 14 is the check-in that decides whether bottle two ships. Day 28 is the refill cycle we engineer around, with dunning, reminders, and an education track that matches the ingredient timing. Budget follows the cohort.

Compliance before creative.

Every claim is checked against FDA language. Every asset is pre-reviewed for Meta ad policy. Your account stops getting flagged, your creative keeps shipping, and the legal team stops being the bottleneck on Monday.

Full rebuild cadence.

The operational commitment on every supplements engagement.

90d
Subscription + lifecycle rebuild window on every supplements audit

Subscription wired to the cohort.

Recharge dunning that actually recovers failed cards. Klaviyo flows timed to the dosing cycle. Server-side events feeding Meta the margin-weighted revenue so the algorithm stops buying one-bottle customers. The stack finally measures what the P&L measures.

Supplements DTC is a subscription business dressed up as consumer goods.

Bottle one barely covers paid. Bottle two is where the business starts. Bottle twelve is where the business actually lives. Every lever in the program, cadence, dunning, winback, quiz, education, creative, is tuned to the refill curve or it is tuned to the wrong thing.

We run supplements programs against cohort LTV, with compliance baked in. We rebuild Klaviyo and SMS around dosing cycles, engineer the subscription ladder against margin, pre-review FDA and Meta policy on every asset, and feed Meta and TikTok the margin-weighted revenue so the algorithm stops buying one-bottle customers. First-purchase ROAS is a reporting line. The refill is the business.

What supplements marketing actually wrestles with

Four problems on every supplements DTC account.

01

Subscription churn

Churn is the single metric that determines unit economics. Every percentage point matters.

02

Compliance constraints

FDA claims, Meta ad policy, and platform restrictions are constant. Creative must comply and still convert.

03

Education as nurture

Supplements buyers need education to stay engaged. Pure promotional flows churn customers faster.

04

Ingredient + benefit messaging

Ingredient sophistication of the buyer matters. Some brands sell on simple, some on studied.

Back of the envelope

Rough math on your supplements pipeline.

Three inputs, a snapshot of your current state. Useful for framing the conversation. Do not build next quarter's plan from it. Real results depend on brand, cohort behavior, subscription cadence, and category compliance.

$ / mo
Total ad spend across Meta, TikTok, Google, and any retargeting.
$
Blended new-customer cost across channels. Different from MER and from first-purchase ROAS.
$
Average order value on the first bottle. We model cohort LTV separately in the audit.
Your current-state snapshot
New customers / mo
~385
First-bottle revenue / mo
~$26,154
Annualized first-bottle revenue
~$313,846

Pure math on the numbers you enter. We do not promise a specific CAC for your brand. What a good program does is move the CAC and refill rate you already have in the right directions. First-bottle revenue is directional. The audit frames the cohort LTV side honestly.

The supplements playbook

Five phases of a supplements program that earns month twelve.

Five phases that work in sequence. Subscription without education burns bottle two. Paid without compliance stalls at creative review. Every layer compounds the one beneath it.

Week 1-4

Subscription engineering

Offer structure, cadence, margin protection, and dunning. Every part of subscription economics modeled and optimized.

Week 2-6

Klaviyo education flows

Education-led sequences. SMS + email. Timed to match ingredient-dosing cycles.

Week 4-10

Quiz-driven personalization

Quizzes that recommend products based on goals. Improves conversion, reduces returns, increases LTV.

Week 6 onward

Winback + dormant reactivation

Margin-protected winback ladder. Sometimes the cheapest customer is the one who already bought.

Ongoing

Paid

Meta and Google with compliance-aware creative. Tight tracking so every acquisition is modeled to LTV.

What we check in a supplements audit

Where a healthy supplements account measures well.

A handful of metrics have clear industry-wide ranges. Others (first-purchase CAC, LTV:CAC) swing dramatically by brand, category, and subscription maturity, so we measure those against your own history and cohort rather than a published benchmark.

Metric
Typical range
Notes
LTV:CAC ratio
Varies by brand
Modeled per cohort in every audit
Subscription conversion
22-38%
Industry range for supplement subscriptions
Monthly churn
4-9%
Industry range for DTC supplement subscriptions
Repeat order rate
35-55%
Industry range for mature programs
Signals

Why we work in supplements specifically.

  • Subscription-engineering and dunning-recovery playbook running in production
  • Klaviyo + subscription platform expertise
  • Compliance-aware creative pipelines
Illustrative engagement

What a typical supplements rebuild quarter can look like.

Generalized example to show the shape of the work. Every supplements engagement starts with a two-week audit. The audit tells us what is actually realistic for your brand, your cohort behavior, and your current stack. We frame the next quarter honestly from there.

What a two-week audit covers
  • Cohort LTV, refill rate, and subscription ladder baseline
  • Meta + TikTok account architecture and creative compliance review
  • Klaviyo + SMS flow inventory against the dosing cycle
  • Recharge / Skio cadence, dunning, and winback audit
Attribution
First-click Server + cohort LTV
Subscription
Single offer Ladder + dunning
Compliance
Post-flag cleanup Pre-review pipeline
Supplements brand cohort and subscription dashboard view
Services we run

What a full supplements engagement typically includes.

Subscription, lifecycle, paid, and compliance running as one program with the same cohort reporting surface.

01 / Traffic

CRM & Marketing Automation

The system that turns leads into deals while you sleep.

  • Meta + TikTok with compliance-aware creative pipelines
  • Server-side events carrying refill-weighted signal
  • Weekly creative promotion against cohort LTV
Book audit
02 / Nurture

Paid Advertising

Campaigns optimized to CPA, ROAS, and closed-won revenue.

Rebuild cadence: 90 days
03 / Close

Conversion Rate Optimization

Fix the leaks before you spend more on traffic.

04 / Traffic

Web Design & Development

Conversion-first websites that load fast and convert faster.

Adjacent verticals

Same playbook, neighboring categories.

Frequently asked

Questions we get asked every week.

  • Can you work with pre-launch supplement brands?

    We prefer post-launch brands with at least 3-6 months of data. Pre-launch engagements tend to be more consulting-heavy and we position those as strategic advisory.

  • How do you handle FDA and Meta compliance?

    Pre-compliance creative review, established supplement brand patterns, and close partnership with your compliance team. Every claim gets checked before it ships.

Reviews

In their words.

Pulled from strategy calls, Slack threads, and end-of-quarter recaps with supplements founders and growth leads. Names and brands anonymized, voice unchanged.

P
Paulo F.
Founder, Thornridge Supplements
3 weeks ago

We were acquiring customers on the first bottle and watching most of them leave before bottle two. They rebuilt the offer ladder, fixed the dunning sequence, and the second-purchase cohort finally started to show up. I stopped dreading the month-three Klaviyo review.

R
Reyna S.
VP Growth, Nightwell Sleep Co.
a month ago

Our old Klaviyo was a stack of generic flows that never mentioned an ingredient or a dose. They rebuilt every sequence around the actual science and the actual cycle. Welcome, education, replenishment, winback, VIP. Subscribers finally read the emails because the emails finally said something.

D
Devin A.
Director of Subscription, Axis Performance Stack
5 weeks ago

We had built the brand on a quiz that was doing nothing. They rewired the five questions into an actual recommendation engine, bundled the stack by goal, and tied it back to the Recharge cadence. Subscription attach on quiz completers moved in a direction we can finally defend.

E
Elena M.
Head of Lifecycle, Veridian Women’s Health
2 months ago

Compliance on hormone supplements is a minefield and the last agency treated it as a speed bump. These folks pre-review every claim against FDA language and every creative against Meta policy before anything goes live. The account stopped getting flagged and the flows started compounding.

Next step

Audit your supplements program.

A 30-minute call. We'll walk your actual numbers and tell you the three things we'd change first.